Skip to Content

Cheddar Mashed Potatoes

Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese for a side dish everyone will love. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy

 Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese. These cheddar mashed potatoes make a great addition to any meal!Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese for a side dish everyone will love. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy

Should I have another cheddar recipe so soon after posting my cheddar jalapeno spoonbread? Um, yes! What can I say, I love cheese in almost everything, don’t you? I should be ashamed to tell you that it took me years to make good mashed potatoes, but I’m not. For a long time I just couldn’t do it and it drove me nuts. My family sat through lumpy, cold, thoroughly unsatisfying mashed potatoes for years until I finally begged my grandmother to tell me what I was doing wrong.Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese for a side dish everyone will love. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy

I knew that my grandmother would have great advice for me. Her mashed potatoes are a dish that everyone clambers to be the first to dig into. Smooth, fluffy, creamy and that first spoonful always uncovers a hidden gem of hot melted butter.Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese for a side dish everyone will love. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy

So here are her mashed potato secrets straight from the source.

  1. Don’t cut your potatoes tiny! There’s no reason to make it more work than it should be, they’re all getting mashed up anyway. Cutting into quarters or so is just fine.
  2. After your potatoes have boiled to the point where they slide off a knife or fork when pierced, drain them. Drain them well!  Make sure no water is left on them before you start mashing.
  3. Mash them thoroughly before you add anything else! And then when you do add cream, butter, milk, salt, cheese, sour cream…anything, make sure that it is at room temperature. Don’t go adding cold ingredients to your hot potatoes or you’ll end up a lukewarm dish.

After you’ve mashed your potatoes and added your other ingredients, taste tested and approved, spoon your potatoes into a serving dish that can be placed in the oven. Place a few  small pats of butter or sprinkle cheese on the top of the potatoes and then mix in to where they are just hidden under a thin layer of potatoes. Place in a hot oven a few minutes, around 10-15, then when you go to serve you’ll have a hidden treasure of piping hot melted butter or savory melted cheese ready for the taking!  Soon you’ll also have people fighting to be the first in the mashed potato line. Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese for a side dish everyone will love. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamyYou might also like these homestyle Side Dish recipes: 

Cheddar Mashed Potatoes

Cheddar Mashed Potatoes

Yield: 6
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 25 minutes
Total Time: 35 minutes

Creamy and fluffy mashed potatoes are taken to the next level of delicious with the addition of sharp cheddar cheese.

Ingredients

  • 2 pounds yukon gold potatoes, peeled and quartered
  • 1/2 cup half and half
  • 2 Tablespoons butter
  • 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese, divided
  • 1 teaspoon garlic salt
  • 1 teaspoon parsley flakes
  • Salt and pepper to taste

Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Set out the half and half, butter, and cheese to come to room temperature.
  3. Place the potatoes in a large pan and cover with cold water. Bring to a boil. Boil for 15- 20 minutes or until your potatoes will gently slide off a fork when pierced.
  4. Drain completely.
  5. Using a potato masher or a mixer, mash the potatoes until they are smooth and no lumps remain. Stir in the cream, butter, 2/3 cups cheese, garlic salt and parsley. Add salt and pepper to taste.
  6. Spoon into a oven proof serving dish. Dot the top with a few tiny pats of butter and sprinkle the remaining 1/3 cup cheese over the top of the potatoes. Stir in so that a thin layer of potatoes covers the cheese and butter.
  7. Heat in the oven for 10 minutes or until the hidden cheese and butter have melted.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 6 Serving Size: 6 Servings
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 252

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a review or a photo! I'd love to hear your feedback!

Light and fresh, but oh so indulgent, strawberry napoleons start with flaky puff pastry layered with fresh strawberries and Bavarian cream, topped off with a perfect swirl of whipped cream. Ready in 30 minutes. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy
Strawberry Napoleons
← Read Last Post
This crockpot roasted chicken recipe is one you’ll come back to time after time. Homestyle chicken is so easy to prepare and so versatile. Recipe on www.accidentalhappybaker.com @AHBamy
Crockpot Roasted Chicken
Read Next Post →

Steve Bullock

Monday 20th of April 2020

This was great - went wonderfully well with an Easter Lamb & Tomato pie I made for the first time - thanks!

Amy D

Wednesday 22nd of April 2020

Hi Steve,

That sounds like an awesome Easter spread. So glad that you enjoyed the recipe. Amy

Alyson Long

Tuesday 20th of August 2019

Looks so yum ! But my heart or waistline won't cope with it unfortunately. #over50problems

Amy D

Tuesday 20th of August 2019

Oh, maybe just a little bit Alyson! Everything in moderation, right? I'll be sad if I ever have to give up mashed potatoes.

Marsha | Marsha's Baking Addiction

Thursday 16th of March 2017

These mashed potatoes look absolutely divine! I need to up my mashed potato game, so I need to try these! :)

Amy D

Friday 17th of March 2017

Thanks Marsha! These are one of my favorite go-to side dishes, you'll love them!

Amanda

Thursday 16th of March 2017

My grandma served hers in the exact same dish!! <3 Great tips... I need to try these next time I make mashed potatoes.

Amy D

Thursday 16th of March 2017

Thanks Amanda! I'm in love with this dish. I recently picked it up at a thrift store for a little bit of nothing. Gotta love stuff that's pretty and practical and will last!

Rosina Harter

Wednesday 15th of March 2017

Yummy. Wish I had an oven

Amy D

Thursday 16th of March 2017

Hopefully you'll get to enjoy these soon friend! :)